| 2023-25 | Marthann Dafft | ||
| 2021-23 | Alyssa Russell | 2020 | Edith Kendall |
| 2019 | Ronda Lane | 2018 | Brenda Olivarez |
| 2017 | Brenda Olivarez | 2016 | Sharon Dickinson |
| 2015 | Sharon Dickinson | 2014 | Shelbi Brewer |
| 2013 | Kathleen Boyle | 2012 | Rosie Perez |
| 2011 | Kathleen Boyle | 2010 | Rosie Perez |
| 2009 | Karen E. Sitton | 2008 | Rona Staberg |
| 2007 | Kim Robertson* | 2006 | Joanne Wineinger |
| 2005 | Ronda Vantroba Lane | 2004 | Wendy Askins |
| 2003 | Cliffa Thomasson | 2002 | Joanne Wineinger |
| 2001 | Betty Ann Thorpe | 2000 | Dena Miller |
| 1999 | Marthann Dafft-Sealy | 1998 | Camilla Munguia |
| 1997 | Charla Beth Francis | 1996 | Patti Denton |
| 1995 | Denise Jennings | 1994 | Vilma Dodson |
| 1993 | Anna Spaulding | 1992 | Laurie Semple |
| 1991 | Linda Scott | 1990 | Gail Childers |
| 1989 | Marthann Dafft | 1988 | Sheila Churchman |
| 1987 | Joye Garza* | 1986 | Sharon Dickinson |
| 1985 | Althea Hilliard* | 1984 | Carolyn Smock |
| 1983 | Sharon Dahlstedt | 1982 | Edith Kendall |
| 1981 | Patty Ratliff | 1980 | Marie Lamb* |
| 1979 | Bonnie Farris | 1978 | Vada Clary* |
| 1977 | Fran Witt* | 1976 | Ruth Rose* |
| 1975 | Mary A. Thulis | 1974 | Maxine Brown |
| 1973 | Eleanor Lathrop* | 1972 | Lula Wilson* |
| 1971 | Barbara Hagley* | 1970 | Maxine Webb* |
| 1969 | Elaine Burns* | 1968 | Anna Pearl Conklin* |
| 1967 | Frances Compton Grubbs* | 1966 | Betty Witcher* |
| 1965 | Juanita Kingery* | 1964 | Francine Finch |
| 1963 | Wilma Curtis* | 1962 | Olga Hoover* |
| 1961 | Anna K. White* | 1960 | Ruth Kelley* |
| 1959 | Jippie Tolbert* | 1958 | Gloria Reinhard* |
| 1957 | Viola Spence | 1956 | Dorothy Faulk* |
| 1955 | Lois Solomon* | 1954 | Jewell Casburn* |
| 1953 | Mary Barrow Brooks-Gribble* | 1952 | Lucille Price* |
| 1951 | Mae Scoggins* | 1950 | Wilma Duke Tadlock* |
| 1949 | Edwina Green Ford | 1948 | Kathryn Burt Quinn* |
| 1947 | Ester Osborne Blake* | 1946 | Ester Osborne Blake* |
| 1945 | Hortense McIntosh | 1944 | Violet L. Crowley |
| 1943 | Dorothy Brooks Hendley* | 1942 | Thelma Akin |
| 1941 | Steve Ann Montgomery* | 1940 | Evelyn Smith |
*Deceased